There’s been a lot of talk recently about the Common Core
State Standards and how important they are in creating a market for nonfiction
writers. That’s nice for us, but
I’m excited about this new approach to teaching way beyond its effects on my
pocketbook. I’ve seen too many
examples in my life of how our citizens don’t know how to read for information
content and how to evaluate what they read.
My first exposure to this problem occurred when I worked as
a teaching assistant in a basic zoology class while in graduate school at the
University of California, Berkeley.
More than once after an exam, a student who received an inferior grade
would come to my office very discouraged.
“I came to all the lectures and I read the text but I only got a C on
the exam—what’s my problem?” I’d
ask them about their reading techniques and it would turn out that they had no
idea that there was more than one way to read. Of course they’d learned to read in school, but as has been
the practice for decades, they learned by reading fiction, which requires a
totally different reading style than nonfiction. You can ‘fast read’ fiction by skimming lightly over some
sections and focusing on following the plot and the emotions of the
characters. That kind of reading
will get you nowhere if you are reading to learn.
Reading to learn requires a form of close reading in which
you carefully follow the text with your thinking brain engaged at all
times. Here are some questions to ask yourself as you read nonfiction text. Does this make sense to me? Am I “getting it” as I read, or do I
need to reread this more carefully?
Am I examining all the illustrations, reading the captions, and
checking to see if I understand what the author is trying to convey? Do I stop frequently and review in my
mind what I’ve just read to see if I’m absorbing the information?
This kind of focused, concentrated reading takes time, and
people like me, who have always read a lot of informational nonfiction can have
a hard time reading fiction. We
become so accustomed to reading carefully, paying attention to every word, that
it’s difficult to finish a novel in a reasonable amount of time. I, for one, haven’t learned how to flip
an internal reading style switch, so a novel takes many hours to complete.
The other problem associated with learning to read through
fictional texts is not learning how to evaluate what one reads critically. What kind of reading do adults need to
master in order to be successful in the world? Nonfiction, not fiction! They read the paper, either on ‘paper’ or online; they have
to be able to read all sorts of forms such as for income tax and contracts for
work. They need to be able to spot
propaganda-style writing and to recognize when they are only getting one side
of the story. The internet has
only made this skill more important than ever, since anyone can put up a snazzy
looking website and fill it up with misleading nonsense or misinformation.
If a student plans to be part of society’s middle class, he
or she also needs to be able to write coherently in order to apply to college, to
apply for jobs, and to communicate within the work environment. I’ve spoken to many college teachers
who need to devote vital time to teaching their students how to write when they
are supposed to be teaching them economics, science, psychology, or some other
academic subject. The CCSS are designed to improve students' writing skills, too.
We can hope that the application of the CCSS will help to
alleviate these problems so that Americans will be able better to cope with the
challenges of our complex new world in which communication has become even more
important than in the past.
1 comment:
Great post, Dorothy. This is a distinction that good students know about. I also think that there are different reading styles for reading to learn. Personally, I read something quickly first, and then go back and reread the more difficult part. At the college level, a lot of content authors assume a certain amount of prior knowledge. If you don't have it, you are lost no matter how carefully you study. When I want to learn something new, I read several approaches to the subject by different authors.
Post a Comment